Monday, May 11, 2009

I Like Big Books and I Cannot Lie

With apologies to Sir Mix-A-Lot.

So in addition to Understanding the Linux Kernel, I'm also reading The Civil War: A Narrative, by Shelby Foote. Here's some impressions I have formed so far:

  • A general's own newspaper editors and politicians are probably his worst enemies. Few things are more valuable in a military campaign than a free hand and the privilege of making his own professional assessment; robbed of these two things by the media and the government, his success becomes failure, his defeat becomes disaster, and his victory becomes impossible.
  • The morale of the troops counts for a lot.
  • Making your own reconnaissance personally counts for a lot.
  • Von Clausewitz was right: The best time to utterly destroy your enemy is immediately after defeating him in battle, as he is retreating in disarray.
  • Von Clausewitz was also right: The hardest thing to do in battle is pursue and destroy the enemy, when you are in disarray immediately after defeating him.
  • The Civil War was essentially a war of Generals. Thousands of soldiers, but only a few personalities in a position to guide the course of the battle.
  • I found it interesting to learn that all the professional Generals had trained together at West Point, and many of them--along with many of the amateur generals in the war--were veterans of the recent war with Mexico.
  • With the same training, and the same experience, the war seems to have hinged greatly on the individual personalities of the Generals involved: Who had better learned the lessons of the classroom and the battlefield. Who could better understand and exploit the situations that confronted him. Etc.
  • Ironclads freakin' rock.

2 comments:

  1. So when was this book written? From what perspective was it written? North or South?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This book was written in the 1950s.

    So far, the perspective seems pretty balanced. I imagine the author hoped to sell copies throughout the country.

    He seems to be pretty even-handed in acknowledging the successes and failures on both sides. Sometimes the Union generals will seem like geniuses, other times like jackasses. Likewise the Confederates.

    And the same is true on the political side. I still can't figure out if Abraham Lincoln was a great American hero and a political mastermind, or if he was a cowardly, incompetent jerk tossed about by the storms of fate. A little of both, I suspect.

    ReplyDelete